Originality and voice
Does it sound like you, or like everything else?
Structure and development
Argument, sequence, chapter logic and reader payoff.
Generic language and repetition
The tell-tale patterns of unedited drafting.
Facts and citations
Claims, figures and sources checked, not assumed.
Copyright and disclosure
Platform requirements and authorship considerations.
Positioning
Title, audience, category and commercial angle.
Cover and metadata
How the book will be found, judged and bought.
Publication readiness score
A plain verdict, plus the rewrite plan to get there.